Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Michelle Kreeger
State Farm® Insurance Agent

Michelle Kreeger

Michelle L Kreeger Agency Inc

2241 W Market Street
York, PA 17404-5516

Formerly the West York Pharmacy

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


2241 W Market Street
York, PA 17404-5516



We proudly serve the residents of York, Harrisburg, and all of Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Delaware, offering a comprehensive range of insurance and financial products. Our services include auto insurance, motorcycle insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, business insurance, life insurance, health insurance, pet insurance, and more. Additionally, we can assist you in saving for retirement, college expenses, or purchasing a new home.

Our team is dedicated to providing exceptional service to our valued customers in West York, Shiloh, Dover, Spring Grove, Etters, Manchester, Mechanicsburg, Grantville, Hershey, Hummelstown, and Lingelstown and throughout PA, MD, and DE. We have a strong commitment to our community and actively promote local businesses through social media and financial support.

With a legacy rooted in four decades of care and dedication, Michelle and her team and continuing the tradition of exceptional service her mother, Jeannie provided for more than 40 years.

Outside of the office, Michelle enjoys various activities such as playing volleyball, dancing, and gardening. And, of course, spending time with her rescue pups, Bear, Boba, and Magic. She's actively involved in local organizations such as the Buy Local Coalition, Southern York County Business Coalition, York Economic Alliance, Children's Advocacy Center, EasterSeals, and the Women's Network of York.

If you're interested in receiving a competitive insurance quote, reviewing your current coverage, or saving for retirement, we invite you to contact us via phone, email, or text. Or stop in! We'd love to meet you! We are here to help you in finding the right insurance and financial services to suit you and your family's goals.

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Are balance transfers worth it?

If you get balance transfer offers in the mail, should you apply? Read more to see if a balance transfer is good for you.

Night driving and headlight glare

A dangerous aspect of night driving is the blinding glare from oncoming headlights. Discover tips to reduce headlight glare when driving at night.

Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself

To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.

View More Articles
Help. Insure. Prepare. That's our office mission. We strive to help you with your assets and your future needs, how to insure those assets and prepare for a strong future. Give us a call .

Our team of licensed professionals is here to help you understand your coverage, protect your assets and prepare you for a successful financial future. Jason can assist you with commercial and business insurance, including auto, business, and Worker's Compensation. Xander, Tom, Lisa, Bret, Wendy, and Jason can help with your car, life, health, home, and more!

Jason Prugar State Farm Agent Team Member

Jason Prugar

Team Leader

Hi, I’m Jason! I’ve worked at Michelle Kreeger State Farm since 2019. As an Insurance Account Representative, I can assist you with Property & Casualty and Life & Health Insurance in Pennsylvania and Maryland. I’m originally from Phillipsburg, NJ but have called York, PA home since 2019. I know a little bit of French and am a published novelist. I’m also directly descended from a passenger on the Mayflower. I look forward to meeting you and helping you find the right insurance coverage!

Wendy Sears State Farm Agent Team Member

Wendy Sears

Customer Relations Representative

Hey there, I’m Wendy! I’m licensed to assist you with Property & Casualty Insurance in Pennsylvania. I was born in Virginia but grew up in Hanover, MD. I now live in Loganville, PA! I’m married to my high school sweetheart and enjoy investigating paranormal activities in my free time. Come visit me for a free insurance quote!


Lisa Bledsoe

I am excited to be working with Michelle and our team. I grew up in the Lehigh Valley of Pennsylvania and I am blessed with two beautiful children. In my free time, I love to garden, paint and take vacations. I have worked in insurance for 10 years and I am grateful that I have had the opportunity to help so many wonderful State Farm customers with their insurance needs. If you need assistance with your life insurance, car insurance, home insurance and more, I look forward to helping you!
Xander Sears State Farm Agent Team Member

Xander Sears

Insurance Account Representative

Hi! My name is Xander Sears. I was born and raised in Maryland, right by BWI Airport. Insurance was a really attractive industry to me after my parents had a house fire and they only had enough insurance because Michelle went over their policy with them. I wanted to help people, just like Michelle did for my family. In my free time I love to watch sports, cook, and traveling to new places. One of my favorite places to visit in the country is Boston, even though their sports teams are terrible and they don’t know how to cook crabs. However, my favorite thing to do, by far, is to help our great customers learn, understand, and use insurance to meet their needs.

Tom Leader State Farm Agent Team Member

Tom Leader

Insurance Account Representative

Hello, my name is Tom! The newest member to Michelle’s team! I was born and raised right here in York, PA. My wife and I were blessed to recently welcome our first child into the world. In the free time that I can find, I enjoy time with my family, taking trips to the Eastern Shore of MD, sports, fishing and the classic campfire. As a State Farm customer for all of my life, I look forward to assisting others in understanding how their insurance works and all of the options that they have! Stop by the office and explore your available coverages today!

Lori Avery Reilly State Farm Agent Team Member

Lori Avery Reilly

Office Manager

Hello, I’m Lori. I’m married and have 3 children, 1 of my own and 2 step. I have been working for State Farm for 36 years. I started with State Farm right out of high school. In my free time I bowl in a league, love music and sport’s. I have played softball and volleyball back in the day. I love animals and have a dog and a cat which are very spoiled. My husband and I love to get away and travel when we can. Looking forward to talking and meeting with you soon!

Bret Sears State Farm Agent Team Member

Bret Sears

Insurance Account Representative

Hello! I'm Bret and I am excited to be a member of Michelle's team! I'm married to my high school sweetheart and we have 4 kids together. Originally a resident of Maryland, I moved here with the family to get away from the business that is the DC area! I am big into sports, especially hockey! I have a long history of helping in the community and I look forward to meeting and helping you with your insurance needs. Give me a call, I'm excited to help!

Kimberly Montague State Farm Agent Team Member

Kimberly Montague